I recently met a patient who was rather hesitant to tell me about her mental health history.
As we spoke, I began to understand why. She was worried that the moment she mentioned anxiety or previous psychological difficulties, her pain would suddenly be dismissed as being "all in her head".
I can understand that fear.
Many people living with persistent pain have been told that their scans are normal, their blood tests are reassuring, or that there is "nothing wrong". Some have even begun to question themselves.
But a normal scan does not mean your pain is imaginary. And having a mental health condition does not make your pain any less real.
Pain is more than a message from an injured body
We often imagine pain as a straightforward process: something is damaged, a signal travels to the brain, and we feel pain.
If only it were that simple. My job would be considerably easier!
In reality, the brain actively participates in our experience of pain. It considers signals from the body alongside our memories, emotions, previous experiences and sense of safety.
An MRI can show us a disc, a joint or an injured tendon. It cannot measure how much pain you experience.
Pain is a protective experience, but the system responsible for protecting us does not always get the balance right.
What does the limbic system have to do with it?
Many years ago, neuroscientist Paul MacLean described the brain using a three-part model, sometimes called the triune brain. He broadly distinguished systems associated with survival, emotion and higher reasoning.
We now know the brain is far more interconnected than this model suggests. We do not literally have three separate brains! Nevertheless, it provides a useful starting point for understanding how emotion and perceived danger can influence bodily experiences.
Networks involving structures such as the amygdala and hippocampus help us respond to threats and remember important experiences. These networks also interact with systems involved in pain.
Think of them as part of a rather enthusiastic security team. Their job is to keep us safe, but sometimes they become so alert that they start sounding the alarm at the slightest disturbance.
The alarm is real, even when the level of danger has been overestimated.
When the volume gets turned up
In pain medicine, we sometimes use the term central sensitisation to describe increased sensitivity within the nervous system.
For example, a touch that was previously harmless may become painful, or pain may persist long after an injury has healed.
Conditions such as fibromyalgia often involve altered pain processing. But sensitisation can also coexist with arthritis, nerve injuries and other physical conditions.
Importantly, central sensitisation does not mean that pain is invented or that there is no underlying physical problem. Several pain mechanisms can exist at the same time.
What about trauma, PTSD and mental health?
Our experiences can influence how the nervous system responds to the world.
For someone living with PTSD, a heightened response to reminders of danger may interact with sleep, muscle tension, attention and pain processing. Persistent pain itself can also worsen anxiety, mood and sleep. The relationship works both ways.
You may have heard the expression "the body keeps the score." It is a memorable way of describing how experiences can leave lasting effects on our responses to stress and threat. It does not mean every painful muscle is storing a traumatic memory, or that everyone with chronic pain has experienced trauma.
I do not assume that.
Nor do I believe that discussing mental health should ever become a shortcut for dismissing symptoms or overlooking a medical diagnosis.
Why I ask these questions
When I ask about your mood, sleep, anxiety or previous trauma, I am not looking for a reason to disbelieve you.
Quite the opposite
As a pain specialist, my role is to examine possible physical causes, recognise the different mechanisms contributing to pain and understand how it affects your life.
That may mean medication, rehabilitation, psychological support, a procedure or a combination of approaches. Sometimes it means further investigation. Treatment should address what is relevant to you, not what happens to fit neatly into a label.
You are also welcome to tell me when a subject feels difficult to discuss. Trust is not something I expect you to hand over at your first appointment.
So, am I imagining all of this?
No. Pain is a real experience, even when we cannot point to one tidy explanation on a scan.
Understanding the connection between the brain, the body and mental health does not make your pain less legitimate. It gives us more ways to understand it, and potentially more ways to help.
And that, to me, is what good pain medicine should be about.
Best wishes

This article is intended for general information and education only. It is not a substitute for individual medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. The appropriateness of any investigation, medication, supplement, procedure or other treatment depends on your individual circumstances and should be discussed with your treating healthcare professional.




